uly 2025 — While Game of Thrones remains one of the most iconic television series of the 21st century, its legacy continues to be complicated by its controversial final season. But what if the signs of trouble were there all along — hidden in plain sight?
Fans and critics have recently been re-examining the series’ highest-rated episode, Season 6, Episode 9 — “Battle of the Bastards” — and many now argue that this Emmy-winning spectacle revealed two of the very problems that would ultimately derail the series in its final season. Remarkably, these issues surfaced three years before Season 8 aired, but went largely unnoticed at the time, overshadowed by the sheer visual and emotional impact of the episode.
Now, with hindsight and renewed critical analysis, “Battle of the Bastards” is being seen not just as the show’s peak — but also as the canary in the coal mine.
1. Spectacle Over Strategy: The Rise of Style Over Substance
“Battle of the Bastards” was celebrated for its jaw-dropping cinematography, practical effects, and immersive battle sequences. Director Miguel Sapochnik delivered a visceral, claustrophobic fight that many hailed as one of the greatest battle scenes in television history.
But upon closer inspection, many now argue the episode prioritized cinematic spectacle over strategic logic — a pattern that would explode in Season 8.
Jon Snow’s battle plan is, by all accounts, reckless. He charges into the open alone, is nearly trampled, and is only saved by the last-minute arrival of the Knights of the Vale — a deus ex machina that lacked build-up. Ramsay Bolton, despite being a sadistic mastermind, makes inexplicably poor tactical decisions. Viewers were too enthralled by the chaos and carnage to question the flaws at the time.
But this preference for visuals over coherent storytelling reappeared — far more egregiously — in Season 8. From Daenerys’ sudden turn to mass destruction in “The Bells,” to the infamously dark and chaotic “The Long Night,” the final season leaned heavily into grand imagery while sacrificing narrative logic.
“You could argue ‘Battle of the Bastards’ was the beginning of the end,” one critic recently wrote on Collider. “It proved that viewers would forgive anything, as long as it looked incredible. The showrunners took that lesson into Season 8 — and pushed it too far.”
2. Character Arcs vs. Shock Value: The Early Warning Signs
The episode also marked a turning point in how the show handled character development — or, more pointedly, how it began to bend characters to fit dramatic moments rather than the other way around.
Take Sansa Stark. Her decision to withhold the information about the Knights of the Vale until the battle is nearly lost has been heavily scrutinized in hindsight. While it made for a dramatic twist, her motivation for not sharing this with Jon — her brother — is never clearly explained. It’s an early instance of plot convenience overriding character consistency.
This problem would grow exponentially worse in Season 8. Jaime Lannister’s rushed return to Cersei, Daenerys’ quick descent into madness, and Bran Stark’s transformation into an emotionless “king” all left fans frustrated with how characters were seemingly abandoned in service of surprising endings.
“Battle of the Bastards” proved that the showrunners, David Benioff and D.B. Weiss, were willing to adjust character logic for maximum emotional payoff. At the time, it worked. But by the final season, that same approach resulted in an ending that felt unearned and disconnected from the rich storytelling that had made the series so beloved.
The Fallout and the Legacy
When Game of Thrones wrapped in 2019, it did so amid immense backlash. Over 1.8 million people signed a petition demanding a remake of the final season. Critics called the finale rushed, incoherent, and a betrayal of the show’s foundation.
Looking back now, “Battle of the Bastards” stands as both a masterpiece and a warning — a brilliant, visually stunning episode that masked deeper structural cracks in the show’s storytelling.
It remains the highest-rated episode on IMDb (9.9/10), and rightly so for its execution. But in hindsight, it may have been the moment Game of Thrones chose cinematic glory over long-term narrative integrity — a decision that would ultimately cost the series its once-unbreakable legacy.
As fans eagerly await HBO’s upcoming Aegon’s Conquest prequel series, many are hoping the network has learned from the past — and that future spin-offs won’t repeat the same mistakes that Battle of the Bastards so brilliantly foreshadowed.
Copyright By Iflex9